If it were possible, I’d encourage any UrbanCorning reader with a tow truck to go to The Diner in Horseheads, steal it, and bring it to Corning. Sure, we have our own diners like Donna’s on Market St and Jelly Beans in Painted Post, but I can’t resist a classic boxcar diner. It’s an atmosphere hard to replicate when it’s done well, and I love seeing what the cooks can pull off in their limited space. The experience at The Diner in Horseheads does not disappoint.
The interior is small but they manage to squeeze in 5 (maybe 6) booths, as well as a good amount of comfortable counter seating. I prefer the counter because half the fun is watching the cooks work their magic. It would be easy to get flustered, but they are masters at what they do. Chatting with the cook I could tell he loved his job, from our discussion about other classic diners to the way he talked up the menu.
Side note: One of my favorite boxcar diners is the Highland Park Diner in Rochester – don’t miss it if you’re up there! I’ve also heard good things about the Wellsboro Diner.
The menu at The Diner is a one-pager, and is supplemented by a daily specials board above the cooks. ?Having closed out The Cellar the night previous, my brain was in the mood for a burger and fries; it was excellent. My special lady friend ordered the special corned beef hash… also excellent.
The Diner has a local history: it was located in Elmira prior to the flood of 72, at which point it was moved to Horseheads. Previously known as Sullivan’s Diner, the new owners spent nine months on renovations, retaining the original woodwork and cool sliding entry doors. It’s a fun atmosphere to take in, and well worth the short drive to Horseheads.
The Diner | Open Daily 6am – 2pm |?59 Old Ithaca Rd, Horseheads?| Like The Diner on Facebook?|?(607) 795-6632
Myles Lasco
Latest posts by Myles Lasco (see all)
- The Vape Flavorium - April 18, 2014
- May The Source Be With You - April 14, 2014
- Spamalot is the Perfect High School Musical - April 5, 2014
Thank you for posting this!!
SOOO good- try the sweet potato pancakes with walnuts – bangin’
If this has been there for years it looks like the same place I ate with my parents! My Dad worked for Dairy-lea out of the Horseheads plant! I remember having a hot roast beef sandwich with mashed potatoes!
I love this diner…
Joe Giles
Yes, Corning needs a diner!! You are so right about The Highland Diner in Rochester–best gyro and rest of menu delicious too.
Susie: I say we bulldoze Mickey D’s and put a 24-hour diner in that location.